Square Pegs and Round Holes
ثبت نشده
چکیده
This article explores the relationship between the social construction of risk, uncertainty and evaluation in the field of development cooperation. It explores the assumption that risk and uncertainty are unusually high in development cooperation. Perceptions of risk and uncertainty are cultural constructs. Several authors have identified perceptions of uncertainty as one of the most important dimensions in organizational cultures. An analysis of evaluation reports shows that risk and uncertainty often emerge as a consequence of operational factors. Evaluations indicate that uncertainty is higher in technological and environmental areas. Furthermore, there are a number of management techniques of handling risk and uncertainty that could be used on development projects. Why have evaluations not influenced the conception of risk and uncertainty more than they have? Three characteristics of the evaluation system are described and discussed. First, the evaluation system is found to send mixed signals in respect of risk and uncertainty. Second, the messages are weak. Evaluation reports are not sufficiently anchored in theory and practice to command respect and belief among a widespread constituency. Third, the signals from the evaluation system have become routine. The messages no longer alarm management and decision-makers. The article concludes by assessing the future of risk and uncertainty management, in particular how evaluation systems may become more relevant in this field.
منابع مشابه
Looking for TALENT in all the wrong places! Finding the talent you need!
Defining Talent Let’s define talent as a combination of three things what we know via training, education and experience, what we like to do, and what we can handle in terms of complexity, and then, let’s define jobs in the same way what you must know, what you must do, and what level of complexity is involved. Once this is done, we can easily put round pegs in round holes, square pegs in squar...
متن کاملThe Reliability and Validity of the Wallin Peg Boards
Institute of Child Welfare, University of Minnesota The Wallin series of performance tests designed for use with very young children consists of four boards, each measuring 3 by 14 inches, % of an inch thick. Each board contains recesses for 6 pegs, similar in size but varying as to form. Board A includes only round pegs, Board B only square pegs, in Board C three round and three square pegs ar...
متن کاملPounding Square Pegs into round Holes: Another Look at the Neoclassical Theory of Predatory Pricing
For more than forty years, economists have routinely rejected the postulate that economic theory should be realistic. Ever since Milton Friedman sketchily outlined a positive methodology for economics, most students of our science have come to endorse Friedman’s view and have claimed that the only quality standard of economic reasoning was its predictive power. Good theories yield fairly correc...
متن کاملVirtual Wedging In Three Dimensional Peg Insertion Tasks
Quasi-static wedging of three-point contacts is investigated, wherein the concepts of virtual and redundant wedging due to a resultant force falling into a friction cone are proposed. We consider the fully-started case of a square peg and hole consisting of two point-surface contacts and one line-line contact. An analysis of the wedging diagram for this highly constrained configuration is carri...
متن کاملThe "almost magical" mobile stroke unit revolution.
Neurology 2012;78:1809–1810 Here’s to the crazy ones, the misfits, the rebels, the troublemakers, the round pegs in the square holes ... the ones who see things differently—they’re not fond of rules ... you can quote them, disagree with them, glorify or vilify them, but the only thing you can’t do is ignore them because they change things ... they push the human race forward, and while some may...
متن کامل